the giant of kandahar 1923 fake Or real? Reviews

The Legend of the Kandahar Giant

In 1923, an American newspaper published a story claiming a team of doctors in Kandahar, Afghanistan examined the body of a man over 8 feet tall who had been shot dead. The report said the strange features of the giant triggered debate over whether it was simply an unusually large human or something else. This initial account launched what became a mysterious legend.

Details of the Alleged Encounter

The story provided several vivid details that fueled intrigue:
– The giant stood over 8 feet tall and weighed over 500 pounds
– It had unusually large bones and teeth, including a size 15-16 shoe print
– Thick hair all over its body and a strange fearsome face
– Villagers who killed it fled in fright at its unusual appearance
– Doctors tried to determine if it was a new species or diseased human

No Credible Evidence or Sources

Despite the compelling nature of the report, no credible sources or evidence have ever been found to independently verify the claims. Repeated searches by cryptozoologists and researchers failed to uncover any documentation or witnesses from Kandahar during that period mentioning such an event. Skeptics argue it reads more like fictional pulp fiction.

Possible Origins of the Story

With nothing found to substantiate the account, theories on where it may have originated include:

• Hoax or tall tale fabricated by the newspaper as creative fiction for readers
• Local Afghan folklore repeated inaccurately by foreigners adding embellishments
• Imaginative interpretation of an unusual circus sideshow exhibit
• Confusion with reports of acromegalic humans, whose condition can cause gigantism

Modern Expeditions and Searches Yield Nothing

In the decades since, numerous expeditions to Kandahar by cryptozoologists failed to uncover any records or local legendary narratives recounting the giant. Afghanistan’s war-torn history makes verifying sources from that era difficult, but you’d expect some trace to remain if such a sensational event truly occurred.

Evaluating the Known Facts

A few key points indicate the giant report seems untrustworthy and likely fictional:

• Lack of any corroborating evidence from original supposed eyewitnesses
• No trace of the story anywhere prior to the 1923 newspaper article
• Absence of similar Afghan folklore when culturally such tales tend to survive
• Cryptozoology researchers unable to find follow up info after exhaustive attempts
• Unverified one-off accounts rarely if ever stand up to continued investigation
• Sensational stories require higher standards of proof vs logical explanations

At the end of the day, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. The Giant of Kandahar story has generated interest for a century yet left zero verifiable proof behind of actually happening as reported. This suggests it was more than likely a fabricated yarn published to entertain rather than a non-fiction case.

Alternative Explanations Considered

While no definitive proof confirms or denies the giant account, other potential origin theories include:

• Misidentified remains of acromegalic giant caused by gigantism disorder
• Severely deformed uncontacted human with unusual genetic mutation
• Exaggerated fable inspired by folk memory of an extinct hominin species
• Hoaxed remains of a fabricated circus sideshow attraction or display
• Skeletal find of an unusually large prehistoric animal mistaken for human

However without credible eyewitnesses or physical evidence, there’s no way to corroborate these alternatives either. They remain unproven conjecture.

 The Bottom Line After Nearly 100 Years

Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. But after decades of failed searches by serious investigators, and zero possibility to confirm essential details, the weight of evidence suggests the story can’t be substantiated and therefore was likely fictional in nature rather than rooted in fact. Unless some startling new information emerges, an “unknown” giant shot in Kandahar in 1923 will probably remain relegated to the realm of intriguing folklore lacking validation. Healthy skepticism is the logical stance when properly analyzing extraordinary tall tales.

read also giant irish greyhound 1902 real or fake? Reviews