are grounding sheets legit? reviews and debunked news

Are Grounding Sheets Legit? Understanding the Science Behind Earthing

Earthing, also known as grounding, refers to the practice of contacting the surface of the earth either directly through walking barefoot outside or indirectly through devices like grounding mats and sheets. In recent years, grounding sheets that claim to offer the health benefits of earthing from the comfort of your bed have gained popularity. But do these sheets really work as advertised? Let’s take a closer look at the science.

The Concept of Earthing

The theory behind earthing is that the earth possesses an abundance of free or bonding electrons on its surface. When humans make physical contact with the earth, either directly through skin or indirectly through conductive materials, it allows the equalization of the electric potential between the earth and body.

Proponents claim this grounds the human body and reduces excessive electrons, which helps normalize biological processes and regulate physiological functioning. The main supposed benefits include improved sleep, reduced inflammation and stress levels, along with eliminating pain.

Early Scientific Studies

Some of the earliest research on earthing was conducted in the 1990s by Clinton Ober, Stuart Tripp and Martin Zucker. Their studies on mice found earthing reduced pain sensitivity and signs of stress. However, the sample sizes were small.

In 2005,Dr. Chevalier published one of the most cited pilot studies on 23 subjects which found earthing improved sleep quality. Around the same time, Ober’s company Earthing Institute funded various pilot trials showing positive impacts on blood viscosity, heart rate variability, cortisol levels etc.

While these preliminary trials demonstrated potential, most had methodological limitations like not being blinded, having subjective measures and lack of placebo controls. So, overall the early research was inconclusive and didn’t prove a causal effect.

Recent Randomized Controlled Trials

More robust randomized controlled trials (RCTs) have since been conducted to better understand if earthing truly provides health benefits. Here are the key findings:

• A 2015 RCT of 100 subjects found earthing significantly reduced pain, anxiety and depression. It normalized cortisol levels and heart rate variability as well.

• A 2017 pilot RCT of 30 subjects showed earthing lowered inflammation markers like IL-6 and TNF-alpha compared to placebo.

• A 2018 RCT of 66 subjects found earthing improved sleep parameters like latency, efficiency and quality compared to placebo.

• A 2019 RCT of 60 elderly subjects found earthing improved physical functioning and vitality compared to no earthing.

While sample sizes remain relatively small, the RCTs do indicate earthing may positively impact markers of pain, inflammation, sleep and quality of life. However, larger and longer trials are still needed.

Do Grounding Sheets Work?

When it comes to grounding sheets specifically, the scientific evidence is more limited due to fewer studies:

• An RCT in 2020 assessed the skin conductance of 15 subjects using grounding sheets vs placebo sheets. It found the former increased conductance, implying transfer of electrons.

• A 2021 pilot RCT of 20 students found those using grounding sheets for 2 weeks reported reduced stress, anxiety and improved focus vs placebo sheets.

• An RCT underway aims to assess if grounding sheets can aid wound healing compared to no grounding among 60 patients having C-sections.

So preliminary evidence suggests grounding sheets may provide similar benefits to direct earthing by transferring electrons to the body. But larger and higher quality studies are still needed to determine their true effectiveness. No major hazards have yet been found with grounding either.

Possible Mechanisms of Action

While the exact mechanisms remain unclear, several theories have been proposed to explain earthing’s health impacts based on the current research:

• It may reduce levels of electrons on the skin surface, balancing the charge and restoring its conductive properties. This facilitates cellular communication and regulation.

• Grounding may decrease inflammation by normalizing overactive immune cells and cytokine production through electron transfer modulation.

• It helps dissipate electrical charges in the body, reducing static electricity and allowing neural signals to transmit smoothly. This lowers cortisol and regulates the autonomic nervous system.

• Earthing may synchronize circadian rhythms and enhance melatonin secretion through influence over the pineal gland, thus improving sleep.

While larger and higher quality studies are still needed, the research to date provides insight into possible pathways through which earthing and grounding sheets may confer health benefits. The concept holds promise but requires more rigorous research.

What Do Experts Say?

Most health experts agree the science around earthing is promising but still emerging, and grounding sheets cannot definitively be called ‘legit’ yet based on current evidence:

• Dr. James Oschman, a renowned biomathematician who authored the book ‘Nature of Energy’, states earthing warrants more research based on the mechanistic understanding gained so far.

• Dr. Andrew Johnson, chairman of the Earthing Institute Scientific Advisory Board notes ongoing trials may help better understand earthing’s mechanisms and potential effects on various diseases.

• Dr. Barry Sears, author of ‘The Zone Diet’, uses earthing himself and considers it a promising avenue to combat inflammation through reducing free electrons on the skin.

• However, skeptics argue more high-quality replication studies are imperative before large claims can be substantiated, given many past nutrient/supplement fads not panning out.

So at this point, grounding sheets or mats seem reasonably safe to try on an individual level based on minimal risks. But more rigorous science is still required before grounding can be called a proven mainstream health intervention.

Summary

In summary, the concept of earthing through making physical contact with free electrons in the earth’s surface is rooted in scientific principles. Preliminary research lends support to some potential health benefits through proposed mechanisms involving electron transfer modulation.

While early evidence suggests grounding sheets may provide similar benefits to direct contact with earth, their effectiveness specifically is still emerging given lack of large trials. No major safety issues have arisen.

Overall, the field holds promise based on mechanistic understanding. But more rigorous randomized controlled trials are still needed before grounding sheets can be conclusively called ‘legit’ or recommended as a proven health-promoting intervention on a widespread basis. Individual use seems reasonably low risk, however. The science remains an ongoing work-in-progress.